aran
(Pere)
22 February 2023 16:07
1
Good afternoon. I think I have read about everything on the forum to connect the 7610… but it doesn’t link.
On a local network it works great… but not in remote. It seems as if it has a port conversor.
In the log I see that it converts a random port to 50001…
2023-02-22 16:59:35.342 INF system: Cannot prepare WF view without rigCaps. Waiting on this.
2023-02-22 16:59:35.350 INF rig: creating instance of rigCommander()
2023-02-22 16:59:35.350 INF udp: Starting udpHandler user: “ea3aji” rx latency: 150 tx latency: 150 rx sample rate: 48000 rx codec: 4 tx sample rate: 48000 tx codec: 4
2023-02-22 16:59:35.350 INF cluster: starting dxClusterClient()
2023-02-22 16:59:35.388 INF udp: UDP Stream bound to local port: 55074 remote port: 50001
2023-02-22 16:59:35.450 INF system: Received CommReady!!
2023-02-22 16:59:35.450 INF default: Setting rig state for wfmain
I have changed ports… disconnected CI-V… and everything I could think of. No result.
Any ideas?
73s
Pere, EA3AJI
roeland
(Roeland Jansen)
22 February 2023 16:26
2
port conversor… can you elaborate?
also can you check if the udp ports are really open from the outsid workd and not being blocked by your ISP for instance?
aran
(Pere)
22 February 2023 16:35
3
Good afternoon.
In this line of the log you can see how it converts port 55074 to 50001.
2023-02-22 16:59:35.388 INF udp: UDP Stream bound to local port: 55074 remote port: 50001
I don’t know if this is relevant…
I have the ports opened as I can access to my router. I have also spoken with my ISP and they have verified it.
roeland
(Roeland Jansen)
22 February 2023 16:51
4
what you mean is PAT, I think.
And: my router/firewall at home maps the udp ports 1:1 so if your router does that too, it’s outside of your network.
this is an example of how it shuld look like, src/dest ports in your router/firewall
--------------------------------------------------------------------
UDP 1350 (192.168.1.110) 1350
UDP 4472 (192.168.1.110) 4472
UDP 50001-50003 (192.168.1.151) 50001-50003
UDP 50011-50013 (192.168.1.110) 50011-50013
UDP 50021-50023 (192.168.1.97) 50021-50023
UDP 50031 (192.168.1.110) 50031
UDP 50041 (192.168.1.110) 50041
UDP 50053 (192.168.1.110) 50053
UDP 50061-50063 (192.168.1.75) 50061-50063```
phil
(Phil Taylor M0VSE)
22 February 2023 17:11
5
Port 55074 is the local (source) port and has no relevance here, the important port is 50001 which is the destination port.
73 Phil M0VSE
aran
(Pere)
22 February 2023 17:29
6
Good afternoon.
Now I have seen that although I have the ports open as UDP in the router… physically they are not like that because when I run a port test it shows them as TCP.
I am going to talk with my ISP
eliggett
(Elliott Liggett)
22 February 2023 17:44
7
You could try using different port numbers from the standard (50001, 50002, 50003).
I have a friend where a lot of his connections were blocked, but he changed to using these UDP ports, which are also used by Zoom, and the problem went away: 8801, 8802, 8803.
Make sure to change the ports in all three places – on the radio, on the router’s port forwarding page, and on your client.
There’s no guarantee this will work, but it might.
–E
de W6EL
aran
(Pere)
22 February 2023 17:57
8
Good afternoon.
I did it before: I put 50011, 50012 and 50013. And it didn’t work anyway.
It’s unusual that you can’t set the port manually on the 7610 and you have to keep pressing + or -.
eliggett
(Elliott Liggett)
22 February 2023 18:09
9
Oh gosh, I forgot about that annoying thing. That’s a lot of button pressing. Maybe try some ports just below 50000.
–E
de W6EL
aran
(Pere)
22 February 2023 18:11
10
Yes… I have seen it… I don’t know how ICOM did not foresee this…
phil
(Phil Taylor M0VSE)
22 February 2023 18:22
11
You can also use the VFO knob to increase/decrease the port number!
aran
(Pere)
22 February 2023 18:42
12
Nice tip!
In spite of this and changing ports… I still don’t have a connection. Let’s see what the ISP says
roeland
(Roeland Jansen)
23 February 2023 17:54
13
is the client you use (where wfview runs) the same inside and outside of your local network?
aran
(Pere)
23 February 2023 18:07
14
Yes… but I have also tested it from the outside and it does not connect anyway.
It’s like I don’t have the ports open… but I have it
This is weird stuff.
roeland
(Roeland Jansen)
23 February 2023 20:23
15
via internal works, outside not. network issue. sure you use udp ports open?
aran
(Pere)
24 February 2023 11:39
16
GM
Yes… sure… I have checked several times.
roeland
(Roeland Jansen)
24 February 2023 16:24
17
if you install nmap on the host,
what do you see if you nmap -sU -p outside of your internal network?
Like:
nmap -sU your.address -p50001-50003
ORT STATE SERVICE
50001/udp open|filtered unknown
50002/udp open|filtered unknown
50003/udp open|filtered unknown
or do you see “closed” or “filtered” ?
eliggett
(Elliott Liggett)
24 February 2023 17:28
18
This is a really good suggestion. nmap is such an excellent tool.
Here’s how my network looks, scanning from 50001-500012 (I have a few radios available remotely):
PORT STATE SERVICE
50001/udp open|filtered unknown
50002/udp open|filtered unknown
50003/udp open|filtered unknown
50004/udp open|filtered unknown
50005/udp open|filtered unknown
50006/udp open|filtered unknown
50007/udp open|filtered unknown
50008/udp open|filtered unknown
50009/udp open|filtered unknown
50010/udp closed unknown
50011/udp closed unknown
50012/udp closed unknown
–E
de W6EL
roeland
(Roeland Jansen)
25 February 2023 15:32
19
Pere,
did you find anything? I assume that you are also using the external IP address to get into your network.
If you need a test-scan and the ISP does not “do things” I can di that for you too.
In that case share your external IP address (preferrably not here on the forum).
aran
(Pere)
26 February 2023 12:57
20
Good afternoon.
Yes… I have tried it before… I get the same result.
Host is up (0.0010s latency).
PORT STATE SERVICE
50001/udp open|filtered unknown
50002/udp open|filtered unknown
50003/udp open|filtered unknown